90 Day Fiancé: Josh Weinstein’s Secret Girlfriend Amid Natalie’s Deportation Fears Prove Her Romances Are Always A Disaster (How Come Things Never Work Out?)
90 Day: The Last Resort star Josh Weinstein has confirmed he’s been dating someone new, leading to yet another failed romance in Natalie Mordovtseva’s life. Natalie was an actress and model in Ukraine when she was introduced to Mike Youngquist by mutual friends. Natalie wished to make it big in Hollywood and that wasn’t going to happen if she lived in the cold woods of Sequim. She found a way out and made it to Florida by dumping Mike yet, staying married to him due to ulterior intentions. Natalie wanted Mike as a backup in case her plan failed.
Kyiv resident Natalie had been married twice before meeting Mike. She wished that modeling agency CEO Josh could be her new boyfriend who would support her financially and also find her jobs in acting and modeling. However, despite being together with Josh for almost four years, he was unable to think of her as his girlfriend. Natalie and Josh’s on-and-off relationship has finally come to an end after 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2 in which they were the only unmarried couple participating.
Josh Seems To Have A New Love Interest
Josh was recently invited as a guest on “The Sarah Fraser Show” podcast. During his interview, Josh confirmed that he and Natalie were no longer together. Josh also seemed to mention that he was now dating/seeing someone from the 90 Day Fiancé franchise itself. It led to fans trying to figure out who this mystery woman could be. Most theories suggested that Josh could have been together with Elizabeth Potthast’s sister Jenn Potthast. Josh had even posted a video with Jenn two years ago which had sparked their dating rumors.
Josh added fuel to the fire by refusing to reveal his new girlfriend’s name, with fans also wondering whether it could be Vanja Grbic or Kara Rojer, who is no longer with Guillermo Rojer. However, in March 2025, Shabooty posted several pictures of Josh with a mystery blonde woman at an airport. Josh was flying from Las Vegas to Phoenix with the woman. Meanwhile, Sarah Fraser showed up in the comments to confirm that the woman in the pictures was indeed Josh’s girlfriend and that the woman will be appearing “at the tell alls.”
Natalie & Josh Had Ups & Downs
According to Josh, he is still friends with Natalie, who has been throwing shade at him on Instagram and has even accused him of bullying her and cheating on her with Sophie Sierra. Josh believes that Natalie gets angry over what she sees on TV and online and reacts. He admits that it’s been a “wild ride” for him and Natalie, but he also continues to care for her. Josh had become Natalie’s “person to call” and her depending on him is what “strung” Natalie and Josh’s relationship along even when he didn’t want to be with her.
Josh’s lack of commitment was the main reason for Natalie and his arguments. She wished to also have a baby with Josh but had already refused her request. The couple had rekindled their romance right before arriving at the resort, but upon learning that Josh had been DM-ing Sophie and planning to take Sophie to Las Vegas, Natalie knew he wasn’t serious about dating her at all. Natalie confirmed her split back in December 2024, spoiling her storyline with Josh, and has since hinted at having a new boyfriend.
Is Natalie Single Again Amid Deportation Fears?
There has even been no confirmed news that Natalie and Mike are divorced. Natalie is still living in California while Mike continues to date his girlfriend Sara in Washington. Mike doesn’t want Natalie back, but she seems to have convinced him to not divorce her until she doesn’t have to fear getting deported to Ukraine. Natalie has been teasing 90 Day: The Last Resort fans about her mystery man with the initials “JS” and seems to be close to making her relationship official with someone who could probably become her fourth husband and her reason to live in America.
